Auto-Editor review: cutting silence, with caveats
Is auto-editor good enough to cut the silence out of a screen recording? For a rough first pass, the few people who mention using it do so without complaint, but the public record leans toward bug reports, so check the rendered file before you publish it.
Auto-Editor is a command line tool, written in Nim, that cuts video and audio by analyzing loudness and, optionally, motion. A comment from asicsp, 2022-08-10 on Hacker News mentions using it to prune silent portions. In another thread, bazzargh, 2022-06-17 wrote "I use auto-editor for this" and explained that komposition, the tool they would rather use, has a problem of its own: "it's bitrotted and isn't maintained any more".
The problems come from GitHub. lijovklm, 2020-07-31 opened an issue about an OBS recording where the "65mb mp4 output file is huge with 529Mb". medicrit, 2021-12-29 hit a macOS crash with "Library not loaded: /usr/local/opt/libxcb/lib/libxcb.1.dylib". Sankyuubigan, 2024-10-31 complained in an issue that "the default automatic silence removal for some reason sometimes cuts words", then raised the same point in a discussion. Most recently, cold-hot-coffee, 2025-09-07 said that after rendering, "I only get the audio and no visibility".
Set that against the numbers. The project dates from 2020-04-30. It sits at 5905 stars next to 735 forks, while the latest commit activity is dated 2026-11-15 and no issue is open. The three issue reports above are marked closed, and the newest mention in the evidence is from 2025-09-07, so how the current release behaves is not covered here.
Support here is slim and lopsided. The positive side is two Hacker News comments from 2022 saying they use it, and the rest is individual users reporting problems on one platform. One licensing note: the README says the online and desktop apps use assets from this repository, while their own unique assets are under a separate proprietary license; the repository itself is under the Unlicense.
- HN@asicsp2022-08-10…using ffmpeg to add the border. So, now I just use the select window option. I also use Auto-Editor ( to prune silent portions.
- HN@bazzargh2022-06-17I use auto-editor for this I'd like to be able to use komposition, which offered a bunch more nice features for screencast editing...…
- GitHub@lijovklm2020-07-31
- GitHub@medicrit2021-12-29
- GitHub@Sankyuubigan2024-10-31
- GitHub@Sankyuubigan2024-10-31
- GitHub@cold-hot-coffee2025-09-07
Related repositories
Still deciding about auto-editor?
One click hands the question to an AI along with this page — see what it says about auto-editor.
